Century's Difficult Problem: Is Tenma Aina more suitable for温水 than Yonamine Anana in "Too Many Defeated Heroines!"? The ultimate showdown between two arguments

In the broad spectrum of romantic comedies, "There Are Too Many Losing Heroines!" has successfully carved out a new territory with its unique "losing heroine aesthetic." However, among the many heroines shining with the aura of defeat, a debate about "who is the destined true love for the male protagonist, Natsuo Wataru" continues to burn fiercely within the fan community. Among them, the most intense battle is undoubtedly the showdown between the "original losing heroine" Kyanna Hachimi (fan nickname: Old Hachi) and the "strongest challenger" Amane Matogi. Is it Old Hachi, with her day-to-day companionship and perfect默契, who has the upper hand, or is Amane, who breaks the deadlock and brings fresh stimulation, more suitable? This article will delve into the core arguments of both factions' supporters.

Absolute Trust Like Childhood Friends: The Stable Advantage of Kyanna Hachimi (Old Hachi)

As the first "losing heroine" to appear in the story, the relationship between Kyanna Hachimi and Natsuo Wataru is founded on an unexpected witness to a heartbreak. From then on, the two developed from unfamiliar classmates into unique best friends who talk about everything, with daily exchanges of sharp-tongued banter.

Core Arguments of the Old Hachi Faction:

• Deep Trust and默契: Their relationship was built from scratch, accumulated step by step. They share many secrets, and Natsuo is always by Hachimi's side, accompanying her through the lows after her heartbreak. This sense of trust cultivated over a long time is difficult for other heroines to match.
• A Haven for the Soul: For Natsuo, who is accustomed to playing the role of a "background character," the time spent with Old Hachi is the most natural and relaxing. Although their interactions are full of teasing, that sense of ease and security has long become an indispensable part of Natsuo's daily life. Many fans believe that the frequency of Natsuo's inner monologues mentioning Hachimi far exceeds that of others, proving her unshakable position in his heart.
• Mutually Developing Feelings: Many analyses point out that the emotional progress between Natsuo and Hachimi is almost synchronous. Hachimi's concern is reciprocated by Natsuo's unconscious special treatment, and Natsuo's efforts gradually shift Hachimi's feelings away from her obsession with her ex towards him. This mutual attraction is seen as the "orthodox" path leading to their ultimate victory.

The Strongest Dark Horse Breaking the Stalemate: The Growing Charm of Amane Matogi

Compared to Old Hachi's "stability," Amane Matogi's entrance was like a strong wind, completely disrupting the original setup. As the student council vice president, her encounter with Natsuo began with a secret about grades.

Core Arguments of the Amane Faction:

• Courage to Actively Pursue: Amane is the first heroine in the series to launch a genuine romantic offensive towards Natsuo himself. From boldly inviting Natsuo to be her endorser in the student council president election to the earth-shattering confession during the sports festival, her straightforwardness and courage forced Natsuo, who always remained on the sidelines, to face the fact that he is liked by someone for the first time.
• A Catalyst for Growth: If Old Hachi is the haven that accepts Natsuo as he is, then Amane is the challenger who prompts his growth. She saw potential in Natsuo that even he was unaware of and pulled him onto a big stage like the student council election. Being with her forced Natsuo out of his comfort zone, revealing a more reliable and dependable side of himself.
• Possibilities for the Future: Amane likes a Natsuo who is "in progress." Unlike other losing heroines burdened by past romances, her feelings are pure, direct, and oriented towards the future. This relationship brings the excitement of "from now on, let's become better together," filled with infinite possibilities.

Core Showdown: Stable Bonds vs. Potential for Transformation

The core of this debate actually reflects two distinctly different views on love:

• Choosing Kyanna Hachimi represents choosing a stable relationship built on a deep history and默契. This is a comfortable, reassuring relationship where Natsuo can be his most authentic self without pretense.
• Choosing Amane Matogi represents choosing an adventure of mutual growth. This is a relationship full of challenges and stimulation; Amane acts like a mirror, reflecting Natsuo's potential and pushing him to become a better person.

Ultimately, does Natsuo need a haven that fully understands and embraces his inner loneliness (Old Hachi), or a partner who can liberate him from his self-imposed limitations (Amane)? This is a question that even Natsuo himself is probably still confused about.

Conclusion: A Multiple-Choice Question With No Standard Answer

Currently, the story of "There Are Too Many Losing Heroines!" is still being serialized, and the final outcome has not yet been revealed. It is precisely this fierce debate of "Old Hachi vs. Amane" that fills the story with suspense and tension. No matter which faction you support, it's undeniable that both heroines have left an indelible mark on Natsuo Wataru's heart, and in the readers' hearts, in their own unique ways. Perhaps the answer to this question lies not in who is "more suitable," but in what kind of person Natsuo Wataru ultimately wants to become.

Browse now There Are Too Many Losing Heroines! merchandise